COLOMBIA:
Helping
Reporters Identify and Deal with Post-Traumatic Stress
Constanza Vieira
ARAUCA, Colombia, (IPS) - A journalist whose emotions have been
blunted by post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) cannot reflect the pain
suffered by others and can cause great harm through their work, says
Colombian psychologist Marta Chinchilla.
The psychologist, who specialises in PTSD, provides assistance to
reporters in the eastern oil-producing Colombian department (province)
of Arauca, a war zone on the border with Venezuela.
In a recent workshop with a group of reporters from Arauca, she tried to
help them identify the symptoms of PTSD, which some people suffer after
they are exposed to a traumatic, stressful event.
The workshop formed part of an Oct. 22-24 seminar in the city of Arauca,
the provincial capital, organised by Media for Peace (MPP) -- an
association of Colombian reporters attempting to provide balanced
coverage of the country's four-decade armed conflict -- with support
from the Konrad Adenauer Foundation from Germany.
Most of the local reporters who attended
work for national media outlets. They are unable to leave the city
for safety reasons.
Although the armed forces have successfully regained control of the
city under the "democratic security" policy of right-wing President
Alvaro Uribe, the army is still fighting the leftist Revolutionary
Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC) and smaller National Liberation Army
(ELN) for control over rural areas of the province, where the
guerrillas have had a heavy presence since the late 1960s.
The paramilitaries, who in many cases work in alliance with the
army, according to United Nations and Organisation of American
States (OAS) reports, have also been in Arauca since 1982, and
represent another source of danger to the local journalists.
Chinchilla forms part of "Resiliencia" (Resilience), a support group
for reporters created in early 2003 by the school of journalism at
the Sergio Arboleda private university in Bogota. She provides free
assistance 12 hours a week in the Colombian capital to any
journalist who seeks her help.
The reporters from Arauca frequently receive assistance from
Chinchilla by means of phone calls and e-mail conversations.
Their professional relationship with her began in April 2003, when
16 reporters from Arauca travelled to Bogota to seek support and
safeguards for their work after receiving death threats from the
guerrillas and the paramilitaries.
The exodus of the journalists left Arauca without any press coverage
for several weeks, with the exception of the tiny local paper El
Cronista, and their presence in the Colombian capital had a major
impact on public opinion.
The majority of the reporters returned to Arauca after they were
assigned two armoured government vehicles and four police guards,
which they have to share among themselves.
The Interior Ministry, which is in charge of providing security
measures for hundreds of journalists, lawyers, trade unionists,
rights activists and others who have received death threats in
Colombia, argues that its budget is too limited to furnish the
Arauca reporters with more armoured vehicles and bodyguards.
Some of the reporters who protested the dangers they are facing lost
their jobs. Others were not re-assigned to cover the civil war.
But the rest make a daily effort to provide balanced coverage, while
their work is closely scrutinised by all of the warring factions.
As one of the reporters said, "the official sources want
unconditional reporters."
According to the Uribe administration, the armed conflict is
actually "a war against terrorism."
The insurgents and paramilitaries, meanwhile, frequently send the
journalists "warnings", and reporters are often called on by the
authorities to explain why they had contact with one source or
another from the groups that act outside the law.
And to make matters worse, sometimes the sources switch sides, which
greatly increases the danger faced by the journalists who have
spoken to them.
Four reporters have been murdered in the past 14 years in the
department of Arauca, and in only one of the cases were the
perpetrators convicted by the courts. But the army soldiers who were
sentenced in that case were only the "material authors", and those
who ordered the killing got off scot-free.
The New York-based Committee to Protect Journalists reported that in
the past decade alone, at least 30 reporters have been killed in
Colombia while attempting to carry out their work.
"As long as whoever is killing journalists knows they will not be
punished, they feel safe continuing to do so," said Patricia Gómez,
assistant director of the national NTC newscast, who also spoke at
the seminar.
"There is no less propitious setting for journalists to work in than
a war," said Gómez, a member of Media for Peace.
"The press can help play up achievements, downplay defeats and
camouflage atrocities. All of the combatants want to use us to get
information out. But when they commit an atrocity, they only want us
to stay far away," she added.
Torture and mass killings of civilians of all ages in rural areas,
sometimes with chainsaws, are among the human rights violations
committed in Colombia's civil war.
It was the high risk and high stress levels faced by journalists in
Arauca that prompted Chinchilla to begin helping them learn about
and deal with PTSD. "The health of journalists is the health of the
country," she said.
Although the armed conflict has dragged on for more than 40 years,
Chinchilla has not run across any other psychologist who specialises
in counselling reporters in Colombia.
She told the participants in the workshop that reporters are among
the groups most susceptible to suffering from PTSD.
Journalists are also the "least protected" group -- from a
psychological standpoint -- of first responders like fire fighters
and others whose work brings them into frequent close contact with
human pain, including psychologists themselves, Chinchilla told IPS.
In her workshops, she attempts to teach journalists how to identify
the mental and psychological impact of war coverage and the possible
physical symptoms, to help them seek out assistance.
PTSD can occur following the experience or witnessing of
life-threatening events such as military combat, natural disasters,
terrorist incidents, serious accidents, or violent personal assaults
like rape.
People who suffer from the disorder often relive their traumatic
experiences through nightmares and flashback episodes, have sleep
disturbances or frightening thoughts, suffer from irritability or
outbursts of anger, or feel detached or estranged -- symptoms that
can be severe enough and last long enough to significantly impair
the person's ability to function in daily life.
Chinchilla explained that PTSD can be difficult to diagnose because
it often occurs in conjunction with related disorders like memory
problems, sexual dysfunction, depression, anxiety, suicidal thoughts
or substance abuse.
Physical symptoms include headaches, gastrointestinal and immune
system problems, fatigue, dizziness or chest pain.
The symptoms develop in the days and weeks following exposure to an
ordeal, and the person often feels overwhelmed or numb, dissociating
themselves from the trauma -- a psychological defence mechanism
against going mad, said Chinchilla.
This "emotional anaesthesia" can last for days or months, she added.
But a reporter with blunted emotions can no longer reflect the pain
suffered by others, and can do a great deal of harm through their
work, warned the psychologist. "When you stop being moved by the
people with whom you enter into contact, you must realise that you
have become numb" and seek out help, she underlined.
"If you cannot connect with that person's pain, people will learn
nothing from your reporting. Your work will completely lose its
quality. The main job of a reporter in a war is to transmit the pain
that people are suffering," she said.
The 16 men and four women taking part in the workshop in Arauca paid
close attention to the description of what is probably happening to
them, although they did not admit it publicly.
"You cannot contribute to society's mental health if you yourself
suffer from pain, resentment, rancour," said Chinchilla. "You
(journalists) help shape the conscience of the nation. If you are
sick, you will project that socially."
"A news item takes only a few minutes to report, but badly
presented, its impact can last for decades," she added.
"The ideal is to react immediately after suffering from a traumatic
situation. It is also important for journalists to recognise their
own limitations: where is your limit, how much pain can you handle
before you get sick," she said.
Colombian journalists are not yet aware of how vulnerable they are
psychologically. But by the end of Chinchilla's workshop, only one
reporter dared even joke that he did not suffer from PTSD.
And the next day, as the seminar continued, the reporters openly
admitted to each other as they chatted in small groups that they
realised that this was what they had been suffering.
Chinchilla said that in each workshop, participating reporters
approach her timidly, desperately seeking help. But they invariably
request a private appointment, and avoid speaking out in public.
|