CASSADAGA,
New York - The extended Jacob Lapp
family, weary of battling local and
federal government officials in two
celebrated cases pitting individual
freedoms against government regulations,
is pulling up its Chautauqua County roots,
with most family members heading to Costa
Rica.
The Lapps,
who hold dearly to an uncompromising set
of moral guidelines rooted in their strong
Mennonite beliefs, have become perhaps
Western New York's most visible critics of
government intrusion.
In the
1990s, they staged two public battles,
with child-protection officials over a
runaway juvenile foster child and with
Internal Revenue Service officials over
filing tax returns.
Their
commitment to leave was cemented Saturday,
with a public auction of their 215-acre
dairy and produce farm, along with a
neighboring 41-acre farm, just outside
this village in rural Chautauqua County,
about 60 miles from downtown Buffalo.
"It's
all about principles," patriarch
Jacob Lapp said by phone from Costa Rica
late last week. "We're firm in our
Bible-based beliefs on how to bring up
children, and the government didn't allow
us to live by our principles."
Jacob and
Barbara Lapp, who moved from Pennsylvania
to their Cassadaga Road farmland in 1971,
have relocated to Costa Rica, along with
five of their 12 children, to farm and
engage in other small businesses. Two
others are expected to move there soon.
"We
have done our share of battles," said
Barbara Lyn Lapp, one of the 12 siblings.
"We want to move somewhere where we
feel safer and where we can live our life
in peace.
"It
really was a very hard decision because we
have strong roots here, and we were
somewhat successful in our runs-in with
the government," she added.
"Every time we took a stand, we felt
it made a mark in the freedom of others.
But we really wanted to live more
peacefully. We didn't like the
conflict."
Spend any
time in the Lapp farmhouse, and you come
away with the impression that the Lapps,
while not enjoying the conflicts, savored
their ability to walk out of the battles
with their principles intact, their honor
preserved.
Jacob Lapp,
76, never has wavered from his principles.
He spent his 67th birthday in Chautauqua
County Jail, refusing to be bailed out,
for harboring the teen runaway. He
routinely mailed back income tax refunds,
saying he hadn't earned the money. He also
rejected farm subsidies and his monthly
Social Security checks, not believing in
either system.
For the
family patriarch, it has always been about
principles - and about standing up for
what he believes is right.
"I
learned earlier in life that if you don't
stand up for what you believe, you'll fall
for anything," he said.
Lapp family
members, though, have paid for that
privilege.
Four family
members spent eight months in the
Chautauqua County Jail for their role in
harboring the runaway juvenile. The family
claims it lost about $65,000 to the
federal government in a settlement over
unfiled tax returns and workers'
compensation payments. And the battle with
the IRS didn't end until the Lapps agreed
to dissolve their successful Cassalea
Farms business two years ago.
The Lapps
also found no way to be assured that their
government battles wouldn't continue. They
still refused to file tax returns, saying
they never could be sure how much money
they grossed in their barter-heavy
business. They also refused to give up
hiring underage children not living on the
farm.
While their
decision to move preceded the recent Iraqi
war, the conflict also helped cement their
view that they were doing the right thing.
"You
could say it makes us feel more
resolute," Barbara Lyn Lapp said.
"We don't approve of bullying at a
local, national or international
level."
The Lapps
proved worthy opponents for local and
federal government officials in two widely
publicized cases:
In April
1993, Donald Stefan took his son, Billy,
then 15, from a diner near a Bradford,
Pa., children's home where Cattaraugus
County had placed the boy after Stefan
lost custody of him. This curious case was
complicated by charges and countercharges
about abuse and maltreatment of the boy by
his father and in the children's home.
The Lapps
then harbored Billy from authorities,
until he was reunited with his father on
the youth's 16th birthday.
The
authorities said the Lapps defied the law,
engaged in illegal acts and made a public
spectacle out of their stance. The family
countered that government officials had
overstepped their authority.
Jacob, his
daughters Barbara Lyn and Rachel and one
son-in-law all walked out of the
Chautauqua County Jail - defiant and
unrepentant - in April 1994, after serving
eight months on misdemeanor charges. The
Lapps refused plea deals that they say
could have gotten them out of jail,
because they claimed they never did
anything wrong.
"We've
been in here for eight months and haven't
submitted to a system that we maintain is
immoral," Barbara Lyn Lapp said two
days before her release.
Nine years
later, she said she thinks both sides
developed a mutual respect for each other.
"There
wasn't anything they could do to make us
back down," she said. "And they
proved the punishment could be pretty
harsh."
Starting in
1991, the Lapps stopped filing federal
income tax returns, claiming that
providing accurate wage and earnings
figures for their dairy farm was
impossible. The IRS, seeking $51,000 in
wage deductions, penalties and interest,
later seized the family's milk checks from
a processor, after the family wouldn't
answer the charges in court.
In 2001,
the family says, the two sides settled,
with the Lapps closing their dairy
business but refusing to sign the IRS
forms.
The cost
was steep, but again, the Lapps wouldn't
budge.
"They
knew we wouldn't back down on
principles," Barbara Lyn said.
"They never made us sign those
forms."
The Lapps
have inspired protests and public meetings
about civil disobedience, and they have
carved out a small following, but they
never quite captured the public's
widespread support.
"A lot
of good people came forward to support us
when the law was bothering us,"
Barbara Lyn said. "But they took it
too lightly. People in general take it too
lightly when the government does unfair
things, like putting us in jail for
standing up for a young man that didn't
have any voice in where he was going to
live."
Her sister
Rachel finds the whole situation sad.
"We
still have our principles, even with the
losses we've taken," Rachel Lapp
said. "But there is something sad
about it. I have lost a certain confidence
in those around me. It's sad when you have
to leave the country of your birth."
Five Lapp
siblings plan to stay in the United
States, at least for a while. But the core
of the family is leaving, after eight
generations on these shores.
"We
don't like the direction that this country
is taking politically," Barbara Lyn
Lapp said. "We have a lot of
appreciation for this country and for what
it offered our ancestors eight generations
ago. But we think the freedoms and the
right to direct your life and business the
way you want to have been slipping for the
last couple hundred years."