Costa Rican Oil Refinery in long battle with tax authorities

recope

(ICR Archive)

August 19th, 2014 (InsideCostaRica.com) The Costa Rican Oil Refinery (RECOPE) has been charged more than $180 million (¢96.6 billion) in penalties and interest by the Treasury as the result of tax audits over the last five years, according to a report by the daily La Nacion.

 

The Directorate General of Taxation (DGT) has audited RECOPE three times over the past five years, finding on each occasion that RECOPE had under-reported its income and was delinquent in its tax obligations.

 

The most recent audit was for the tax year 2010-2011.  For that year, auditors determined that RECOPE owed ¢7 billion ($13.2 million), despite the fact RECOPE reported zero income.

 

The year previous, tax authorities demanded payment of ¢60 billion ($113.2 million) after conducting audits of RECOPE’s tax years between 2004 and 2008.

 

So far this year, RECOPE has reported losses of ¢10 billion ($18.8 million) between January and June.

 

Claudio Ansorena, general manager of the State-owned company, said tax auditors themselves are principally to blame for the situation.  RECOPE believes that it is exempt from income tax as a State-owned company – a view not shared by the Treasury.

 

RECOPE and tax authorities have faced off over the issue for years, and RECOPE blames many of its financial woes on tax authorities.

 

Tax authorities believe that “excess” revenue generated by RECOPE – which would traditionally be defined as “income” or “profit” for a private enterprise – is subject to income tax.  RECOPE, for its part, argues that such revenues are not profit, as they are held in reserve for future investments in infrastructure and other future needs.

 

“RECOPE is in a delicate situation.  If we pay [taxes], we have to find the money, either by taking on debt or by dropping plans for future investments,” Ansorena said.

 

“If RECOPE persists with the same behavior (not paying taxes), we will continue to conduct audits to correct them,” said Carlos Vargas, director of Taxation.

 

online poll by Opinion Stage


costa rica news

ATTENTION: If you are seeing this message,

If you appreciate this report, please consider supporting ICR.


Subscribe via E-Mail

Get all of our news delivered fresh to your inbox every morning! Just tell us your name and where to send it using the form below.

PS – We hate spam too. We don’t sell or share our list with anyone, and we never send commercial email.

* = required field


Like us on Facebook and receive our news in your timeline

  • prdatki

    The top 100 People of Costa Rica Departments should be fired with no benefits, ICE, AWA, and the rest, no elected official should receive any benefits.

  • michaelwink

    Sounds like a sweet precedent they could set here, as basically every business could argue their profit one year is being held in reserve for future investment.

  • Ken Morris

    Sounds like something the courts need to resolve. I can see the matter either way, and it probably doesn’t matter which way it is resolved since tax payments would likely just be passed along to the consumer in higher prices, but there does apparently need to be agreement as to what the law really requires.

    I guess I’d prefer that RECOPE be taxed, mainly because subsidizing oil strikes me as precisely the wrong thing to do from both an environmental and quality of life standpoint, but this issue doesn’t sound like a matter of opinion to me. I think the question is what the law actually requires.

  • turbooperator

    While it doesn’t seem to make much sense that the government would tax itself (asi es Costa Rica) , RECOPE’s own Management Rule #9 (found on it website) says that it (RECOPE) is subject to, and will pay taxes in accordance with the law.

  • Lav

    If they want to be classified as state owned, maybe they should have state approved salaries… which of course should be approved by the citizens of Costa Rica.

    • turbooperator

      If anyone is interested, The salaries of RECOPE can be found here:
      https://www.recope.go.cr/etica-y-transparencia/salarios-por-puesto/

      They don’t seem to be out of line with the rest of the country.

      • mhogan

        Except perhaps for their sheer number. How many people work at Recope. Ans: About half of them. Are benefits also reported? Think not. That’s where government employment pays off.