After more than four years, Costa Rican tragedy will go unpunished

Stock/archive image.

Archive image.

March 3rd, 2014 (InsideCostaRica.com) A tragedy still in the minds of many Costa Ricans will go unpunished and the victims’ families will go without compensation after a criminal judge dismissed the case on Friday.

 

On October 22, 2009, a passenger bus crossing a suspension bridge over the Tarcoles River in Turrubares plunged into the river below after the bridge collapsed, killing five and injuring thirty.

 

On Friday, criminal judge Kenneth Alvarado Aguirre dismissed all charges against Karla Gonzalez Carvajal, former Minister of Public Works, Alejandro Molina Solis, former director of the National Roads Authority (Conavi), Benjamin Sandino, former director of road maintenance at Conavi, Maria Ramirez Gonzalez, former head of bridges for the Ministry of Public Works and Transport (MOPT) and Victor Manuel Salas Vega, who drove the bus.

 

The judge cited a lack of evidence against the accused, determining that the collapse of the bridge should be considered a “fortuitous event or accident.”

 

The judge also dismissed a civil lawsuit against the State brought by victims’ families, advising them to seek assistance from the civil courts.

 

The accident occurred at 6:30am on October 22, 2009, when the bus driven by Victor Manuel Salas Vega and carrying 38 passengers attempted to cross the suspension bridge, which was in poor enough condition that signs had been placed at the bridge warning that vehicles weighing more than four tons should not use the bridge.

 

The bridge totally collapsed, plunging the bus and its passengers into the Tarcoles River below, killing five and injuring thirty.

 

The report of a subsequent investigation determined that the bridge collapsed due to “overuse” rather than the weight of the bus.

 

Although Friday’s decision may be appealed, it is unlikely that the judge’s ruling will be reversed.

costa rica news

ATTENTION: If you are seeing this message,

If you appreciate this report, please consider supporting ICR.


Subscribe via E-Mail

Get all of our news delivered fresh to your inbox every morning! Just tell us your name and where to send it using the form below.

PS – We hate spam too. We don’t sell or share our list with anyone, and we never send commercial email.

* = required field


Like us on Facebook and receive our news in your timeline

  • Ralph Carlson

    These stories seem to be getting more common every day – lack of responsibility is rampant – “no es me culpa”
    I have a couple of stories of my own where the judge has dismissed obviously criminal behavior – ie- developers collecting millions, selling land they didn’t own and being let off by the court for “lack of evidence”. I no longer have faith in the Costa Rica justice system – I think it is rigged just to make money for lawyers and thieves.

  • mhogan

    Bus driver being Tico explains his “no culpa” (had he been expat, different story); of course the State is never at fault. Same old, same old. Two sets of laws. So typical of kleptocratic banana republics.

  • Old Nam Warrior

    and that’s one of the reasons we left Costa Rica…a rigged Constitution,by the wealthy,for the wealthy

    • Jerry

      How long did you stay and when did you leave?

      • Lawrence Horn

        2003 to 2012

  • Frank Castle

    My Mom is retired near San Jose and likes it, warts and all, but soon, when I head that way, Panama seems to be a better bet. I have visited there and felt very much at home with the people. Costa Rica is fine towards the South but I always felt I had to be on guard of myself and my property.