Subscribe via E-Mail

Get all of our news delivered fresh to your inbox every morning! Just tell us your name and where to send it using the form below.

PS – We hate spam too. We don’t sell or share our list with anyone, and we never send commercial email.

Wednesday, November 25th, 2015  |  USD: Buy 526.40 / Sell 538.98
20 years

Forensic doctor rules out suicide in Bender case

Anne Maxin Patton trial

Photo: Luis Navarro

Editor’s note: This story is continuing coverage of the murder trial of Anne Maxin Patton.  If you are unfamiliar with the case, you may want to read this story first. 

January 17th, 2013 ( The defense of U.S. citizen, Anne Maxin Patton, on trial since Monday on charges of murdering her huband, John Felix Bender, received a serious blow as a forensic doctor “ruled out,” the chance that her husband committed suicide.  Bender died from a gunshot wound to the head.


In her initial testimony on Monday, Patton stated that she did not murder her husband, but rather that Bender had the gun to his own head, intending to take his life, and while attempting to take the gun from her husband, it fired, killing him.


The forensic doctor, Greichel Flores Sandi provided her statement to the court via videoconference from her office in San Joaquin de Flores, Heredia.  The doctor said that because of the trajectory of the bullet, it was impossible that Bender shot himself.  The bullet that killed Bender entered the right side of his head, though Bender was left-handed.


“He had a gunshot wound in the right occipital region, that wound was six centimeters away (towards the right) from the middle line of the neck. We considered the possibility of access (with the left hand) that the victim had of holding the gun and shooting, in addition to the trajectory of the bullet,” said Flores.


However, when asked by the defense attorney, Fabio Oconitrillo, about the possibility of Bender shooting having shot the gun with his right hand, the doctor stated that she based her investigation on the fact that he was left-handed.


Patton said on Monday that she has had a neurologic illness for many years that does not permit her to manipulate firearms, among other disabilities.


However, doctor Flores stated yesterday that she performed a physical exam on Patton while she was hospitalized in CIMA Hospital on February 4th, 2012, almost a month after Bender’s death, and that Patton had no difficulty whatsoever in moving her hands and limbs.


“According to the physical exam that I performed, she had no functional deficit, she was able to move her upper limbs with no problem,” she said.


Enhanced by Zemanta

costa rica news

ATTENTION: If you are seeing this message,


Get our news delivered fresh to your inbox every morning.

Click here to subscribe to our email list. We hate spam too and never send commercial email.

Like us on Facebook and receive our news in your timeline

  • Kelley Archer

    Ann Bender was railroaded. No double jeopardy in Costa Rica so you can be tried as many times as it takes till they get a guilty verdict and your assets. Witnesses completely changed their story conveniently in 2nd trial. John and Ann’s $70mn trust managed by a nefarious lawyer named Juan de Dios Alvarez stole 20 million, also all of the trust’s liquid assets – approximately $40mn – have disappeared. In addition, property titles to trust assets have been transferred to companies outside the trust umbrella. Costa Rican government appointed an interim trust manager named Mario Gomez who has not provided any management of the estate nor paid any of the reserve employees or disbursed any money to Ann to cover her legal or medical fees. Go figure…if you plan on retiring outside the U.S. this is what you can expect when living in a foreign country with a corrupt legal system.

    In an unrelated separate case, the couple was
    accused of smuggling rare gems. Officials carried suitcases full of diamonds,rubies, emeralds, and sapphires out of their home. The gems were worth $8.5million. No doubt that will disappear into some government officials coffers too!

  • duke ster

    Actually I am ashamed that I am flip flopping on this trial–I completely forgot that she said she was there and they struggled over the gun—Of course that shoots down my theory that she was railroaded.—This can only mean that she is indeed guilty because of the facts such as he shot himself in the right side of his head when he was left handed. YES I am ashamed of my theory that she was railroaded. Let the trial bring out the facts and hopefully the truth will come out and the guilty parties be judged.
    But why was the boyfriend killed? Indeed his death has all the hallmarks of a “HIT”, being that he was a trainer and in good health–in fact excellent health. That doesn’t mean that he actually could have dies from a blocked artery but it would be good if he had an autopsy because that would determine if he had a heart blockage. To die from another attack of some kind is pretty far fetched.

    The question always is…. who will benefit from each death?
    We all realize wife will collect if she escapes justice.
    The state will benefit if she is jailed because the jewels will disappear into the hands of those who guard them.
    Who will benefit from the boyfriends death? ..answer- AGAIN -The state guardians of the jewels.because the wife’s biggest helper is out of the way. Someone wanted the boyfriend dead because THEY want the jewels.

  • duke ster

    Juan de Dios Alvarez, hmmmm. Sets this whole thing in action because he knows all the assets. Makes secret deals dividing up the spoils. Gets the law to file smuggling charges in order to get the jewels out to be divvied up. He already has his hands on the property titles etc. So he is salivating to set this robbery in action. But how does he get Ann to say she fought with her husband over the gun and that he shot himself?
    This could only mean that Juan was just waiting for something like this to happen.
    Now that Ann is in jail Juan + company want her to stay there and remain helpless and because her boyfriend is helping her and there is the possibility that she could get out–They hire a hitman to get the cyanide in him to get him out of the way. The whole thing seems like it could have been set up by the Lawyer Juan de Dios–the mysterious part is Ann saying her husband was trying to commit suicide.

Popular Content